What You Need to Know About Foundation Tar Coating
Foundation tar sealer, a black, bituminous coating used on basement walls for over a century, is not a true waterproofing solution. Here’s what you need to know before relying on it to protect your basement:
Quick Facts About Foundation Tar Sealer:
- What it is: An asphalt-based dampproofing compound (not true waterproofing)
- What it does: Resists soil moisture and water vapor through porous concrete
- What it doesn’t do: Stop water under hydrostatic pressure or bridge new cracks
- Coverage: 3 gallons covers approximately 100 square feet
- Drying time: 4-8 hours in ideal conditions, up to 7 days in cold/damp weather
- Lifespan: 10+ years for dampproofing if properly applied
- Cost: Less expensive initially than modern alternatives, but often requires supplemental waterproofing
The Critical Distinction: The key distinction is that tar is for dampproofing (blocking soil moisture), not waterproofing (stopping liquid water under pressure). For basements with active leaks or high water tables, tar alone is insufficient and will likely fail.
As foundation experts say, “water always wins.” Persistent water pressure will eventually bypass tar coatings, especially at cracks or weak points in the application.
I’m Darin Garvey of Basement Waterproofing Scientists. With 30 years of experience, I’ve inspected hundreds of basements where foundation tar sealer was applied decades ago—some holding up, many completely failed. Understanding when tar is appropriate (and when it’s not) can save you thousands in future repairs.
The Application, Pros, and Cons of Foundation Tar Sealer
For generations, foundation tar sealer was the go-to method for keeping dampness at bay. It was available, easy to apply, and did a decent job stopping moisture from seeping through porous concrete. But just because something has a long history doesn’t mean it’s the best solution. Let’s walk through how tar coating works, its benefits, and its significant shortcomings.
Understanding the Application of a Foundation Tar Sealer
Applying foundation tar sealer requires careful preparation and the right conditions. For existing foundations, this involves excavating to expose the exterior wall to the footing. The wall must be thoroughly cleaned of all dirt and debris, and any existing cracks must be repaired with a proper sealant—tar itself cannot bridge cracks. The thick coating is then applied evenly with brushes, rollers, or sprayers, typically at a rate of three gallons per 100 square feet. Drying takes 4-8 hours in ideal weather but can extend up to a week in cold or damp conditions, and the application should only be done in temperatures above 60°F.
The Advantages of Using Tar Coating
When used for its intended purpose of dampproofing, foundation tar sealer offers several benefits:
Creates a seamless barrier. When applied correctly, tar forms a continuous membrane that is effective at stopping water vapor.
Excellent at preventing dampness. It stops the capillary action that allows moisture from damp soil to wick through porous concrete.
Surprisingly durable. The material has high tensile strength, meaning it resists punctures under normal soil conditions.
Budget-friendly upfront. Tar coating has a lower initial cost than many advanced waterproofing membranes.
Can last over a decade. When properly applied and not subjected to significant water pressure, a tar coating can provide effective dampproofing for ten years or more.
The Disadvantages and Limitations of Tar
After 30 years inspecting basements across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware, I’ve seen countless tar coating failures. Understanding these limitations is key to avoiding future repairs.
It’s not true waterproofing. This is the most critical limitation. Tar is a dampproofer that resists moisture, but it cannot withstand liquid water under pressure. If your basement has standing water, tar will fail.
Hydrostatic pressure is its kryptonite. The force of groundwater will exploit any tiny pinhole or weak point in the tar coating, leading to failure.
Won’t bridge new cracks. As foundations settle, new cracks form. Brittle tar cracks along with the concrete, creating a new entry point for water.
Becomes brittle over time. Temperature fluctuations and soil chemistry cause tar to lose its flexibility, eventually flaking and failing.
Those toxic fumes are no joke. Traditional tar releases volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during application, a health hazard requiring professional protective equipment.
Tar Coating vs. Modern Waterproofing: An Effectiveness Showdown
When protecting your foundation, the choice between traditional foundation tar sealer and modern methods is about selecting the right tool for the job. While tar was once a standard, today’s solutions are far more capable of handling serious water issues. Think of tar coating as an umbrella in a hurricane—helpful for a drizzle, but inadequate for real water pressure.
Modern waterproofing solutions address every weakness of tar.
- Elastomeric coatings are liquid-applied membranes that stay flexible, stretching to bridge minor cracks as the foundation moves.
- Liquid rubber membranes are the gold standard, curing into a seamless barrier with extraordinary flexibility (some stretch up to 900%). They bridge new cracks and can last 50 years or more. They are also typically non-toxic and VOC-free.
- Cementitious coatings combine cement and polymers to create a durable waterproof layer, effective for interior use but less flexible than rubber.
- Dimple drainage boards are rigid sheets that create an air gap against the foundation, allowing water to flow down to a perimeter drain. This relieves hydrostatic pressure instead of trying to block it.
- Interior drainage systems intercept water at the basement’s perimeter and direct it to a sump pump, offering effective protection without exterior excavation.
At Basement Waterproofing Scientists, we often combine methods, such as a liquid rubber membrane with a dimple board and perimeter drain. This layered approach manages both moisture and hydrostatic pressure, something tar can’t do alone. While tar is cheaper upfront, a comprehensive waterproofing system (typically $4K-$8K) is a better investment. It prevents costly future repairs from water damage and mold, saving homeowners from paying twice: once for the failed tar and again for a real solution.
| Feature | Tar Coating (Dampproofing) | Liquid Rubber Membranes (Waterproofing) | Dimple Boards (Drainage/Waterproofing) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flexibility | Low (becomes brittle over time) | High (e.g., 900% elongation), remains flexible | Rigid, but creates flexible drainage plane |
| Crack-Bridging Ability | Poor (cracks with foundation movement) | Excellent (stretches to bridge new and existing cracks) | None (relies on underlying membrane) |
| Durability | Decent for dampproofing (10+ years), but prone to failure under pressure | Excellent (20+ year track record, 50-year life expectancy for some products) | Excellent (high-density polyethylene, long-lasting) |
| Application | Brush, roller, spray; requires careful surface prep | Brush, roller, spray; requires clean surface, often no primer for exterior | Installed mechanically against wall; requires proper backfilling |
| Hydrostatic Pressure Resistance | Poor (designed for dampness, not pressure) | Excellent (forms an impermeable, flexible barrier against pressurized water) | Excellent (creates air gap to relieve pressure, directs water away) |
| Health/Environmental | Releases toxic fumes (VOCs), petroleum-based | Often non-toxic, low/zero VOCs, more environmentally friendly | Inert material, no fumes |
The table above clearly shows that in every category that matters—flexibility, durability, and especially hydrostatic pressure resistance—modern waterproofing methods outperform tar coating. Choosing the right materials from the start saves you money and stress for decades to come.
Failure, Risks, and Costs: The Long-Term Reality
Even when applied correctly, foundation tar sealer is not a permanent solution, especially when conditions push beyond its dampproofing limits. Understanding what failure looks like can save you from extensive water damage and repair costs.
Recognizing When Your Foundation Tar Sealer is Failing
The warning signs of a failing tar coat announce themselves on your interior basement walls, often after moisture has already been seeping through for some time:
- Peeling and blistering: Paint or coatings on basement walls bubble or peel as moisture pressure builds behind them.
- Cracking: As tar ages and becomes brittle, it cracks along with any foundation movement, creating direct paths for water.
- Efflorescence: A white, powdery mineral deposit on concrete, which is clear evidence that water is passing through the wall.
- Damp spots: Visible wet or discolored areas on walls that may feel cool or clammy.
- Musty odor: An earthy, moldy smell that indicates persistent dampness and high humidity.
- Mold growth: Black, green, or white patches on walls or stored items are a serious health concern. If you have mold covering more than 10 square feet, the EPA recommends professional help. You can find detailed health and safety guidelines for mold cleanup on their website.
If you’re seeing any of these warning signs in your Pennsylvania, New Jersey, or Delaware basement, it’s time to invest in real waterproofing.
Health, Environmental, and Cost Considerations
The true cost of foundation tar sealer goes beyond its initial price.
- Health Concerns: During application, tar releases volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that can irritate the skin, eyes, and respiratory system.
- Environmental Impact: As a petroleum-based product, traditional tar is not an environmentally friendly choice.
- The Real Cost: Tar’s low upfront cost is deceptive. When it inevitably fails under water pressure, the cost of repairing water damage, remediating mold, and installing a proper waterproofing system (often $4K-$8K) far exceeds any initial savings. At Basement Waterproofing Scientists, our 30 years of experience confirm that fixing the problem correctly the first time with a guaranteed solution is the most cost-effective approach.
Frequently Asked Questions about Foundation Tar Sealers
We hear a lot of questions from homeowners trying to make sense of the black coating on their foundation walls. Here are the answers to the questions we get asked most often.
How long does foundation tar coating last?
In ideal, low-moisture conditions, a properly applied tar coating can provide dampproofing for over a decade. However, its lifespan is significantly reduced by:
- Poor application: Inadequate cleaning or thin coats lead to early failure.
- Harsh conditions: Freeze-thaw cycles and acidic soil make the tar brittle faster.
- Hydrostatic pressure: This is the main cause of failure. Persistent water pressure will overwhelm tar, causing it to fail within a few years.
- Foundation movement: As the house settles, the brittle tar cracks, allowing water intrusion.
While it can last for basic dampproofing, it’s not a permanent waterproofing solution.
Can you apply new sealant over old tar?
Generally, no. Applying a modern waterproofing product over old, brittle, or peeling tar often leads to adhesion failure. Your new coating is only as strong as the surface it’s sticking to. Most modern membranes require a clean, stable surface to bond correctly, and old tar is often contaminated and chemically incompatible. For lasting results, the old tar should be removed. Always consult the new product’s manufacturer guidelines or get a professional assessment to determine the correct preparation.
Is tar coating enough to stop a basement from leaking?
No. Foundation tar sealer is a dampproofer, not a waterproofer. It resists moisture from damp soil but cannot stop active leaks or water under hydrostatic pressure. If you have puddles, active leaks, or a high water table, tar will fail. True leak prevention requires a comprehensive waterproofing system, which may include exterior membranes, interior drainage, and a sump pump. At Basement Waterproofing Scientists, we use specialized equipment to diagnose the exact source of leaks and design a targeted, guaranteed solution that fixes the problem for good.
Conclusion: Moving Beyond Tar for a Truly Dry Foundation
For decades, foundation tar sealer was the standard for dampproofing against soil moisture. However, as we at Basement Waterproofing Scientists have seen over 30 years, it has critical limitations. Tar is a dampproofer, not a waterproofer. It fails under hydrostatic pressure, becomes brittle, and cracks as foundations settle, leading to leaks, mold, and expensive damage. Water always wins against an insufficient barrier.
The good news is that modern waterproofing technologies have revolutionized foundation protection. Liquid rubber membranes that stretch to bridge cracks, dimple boards that relieve water pressure, and interior drainage systems offer permanent solutions with lifespans of 50+ years. These methods address the root causes of water intrusion in ways tar never could.
An investment in comprehensive waterproofing, typically between $4K and $8K, secures your property’s value and ensures a healthy, dry basement. At Basement Waterproofing Scientists, we use specialized equipment to pinpoint leaks, allowing us to design targeted solutions backed by our lifetime guarantee. We fix the problem right the first time.
If you’re living with an aging tar coating or dealing with moisture in your Pennsylvania, New Jersey, or Delaware basement, it’s time for a professional assessment. We’ll provide an honest evaluation and a permanent solution.
Learn more about modern foundation sealants
